Republican Fear Tactics Won’t Work With Jewish Voters
In his closing statement at this week’s Michigan Senate debate, Republican Mike Rogers said, “Jewish Democrats who are afraid for their children…you’ll have a home with us.” Trying to appeal to the Jewish electorate in Michigan – the majority of which are Democrats – Rogers attempted to make Jewish voters feel welcome in the GOP by tapping into the legitimate fears so many of us have about our children’s future.
I am one such Jewish voter. I was raised in East Lansing, Michigan, which Mike Rogers represented in the House of Representatives for 14 years, and I am fearful about my children’s future. I am deeply concerned about the startling rise of antisemitism and growing anti-Israel sentiment, just as I worry about my children’s freedoms and rights, including voting rights, free speech, reproductive freedom, and the right to attend school without being shot.
The problem with Rogers’ argument is that his political home, the Republican Party of Donald Trump, is perpetuating the vast majority of my fears, not confronting them.
For example, upon hearing the horrific details of last week’s school shooting in Bend, Oregon – along with the fact that it’s the 52nd school shooting this year, the 36th in a K-12 school – two of my teenage boys asked me if their school would be the next target. The fact that I can’t answer that question with a definitive “no” is my number one fear when it comes to my children’s future.
Fears of gun violence are not abstract and not uniquely Jewish, but those fears are almost uniquely American, and Republicans have uniquely failed us. Since the first school massacre in 1999 at Columbine – and the hundreds since – Republicans, including former Rep. Mike Rogers, have had countless opportunities to improve gun safety measures, and they have chosen not to. Republicans’ decades-long refusal to address gun safety is perpetuating my fears.
In the closing weeks of this election, Republicans are invoking fear as a political tactic, tapping into Donald Trump’s culture war. We have seen the GOP engage in Islamophobia, homophobia, transphobia, xenophobia, and antisemitism – as well as making false claims of non-citizen voting and an alleged Democratic “communist” takeover – as a means of manipulating hate and fear in these midterms.
Republicans are closing this election not by presenting clear plans to address the affordability crisis, war with Iran, and real issues facing the American people, but by waging Trump’s tired and hateful culture war. It’s going to backfire.
According to CNN, Trump’s closing argument for supporting Republicans in the midterms is “that White, Christian culture could be destroyed unless his Republican monopoly on Washington power is preserved…In one of the most foreboding closing arguments of any of his political campaigns, Trump is flinging racially charged rhetoric; conjuring Islamophobic paranoia; and stirring up false visions of kids being mutilated in mass transgender surgeries without parental consent. He’s also acting as an arbiter of others’ faith and American identity.”
This won’t work with Jewish voters. We won’t cower or be pushed into a political corner – especially not the Republican corner – based on fear, hate, xenophobia, and lies. We may be legitimately fearful for our children’s future – I certainly am – but Donald Trump and the party he controls are perpetuating the root causes of most of our fears. Democrats aren’t perfect, but Republicans under Trump aren’t the answer. We cannot overcome our fears by turning against each other.
Donald Trump’s Party, of which 100% of Republicans on the ballot in 2026 are now a part, is what has led to Americans being shot in the streets by ICE; to a Christian nationalist “crusader” leading our military; to the Department of Justice demanding state voter rolls and purges of select voters; to the people of Ukraine being betrayed and killed as a favor to Vladimir Putin; and to a president ruling with impunity, getting away with rampant corruption, chaos, and cruelty for the past 21 months because the Republican controlled Congress refuses to stand up to him.
These issues make me fearful, but they will not be overcome with more fear. They can only be addressed at the ballot box, by electing Democrats who share our values and will fight for meaningful policies that will change the trajectory of our country in Congress.
This doesn’t mean blindly supporting every Democrat on the ballot in 2026. JDCA has selectively supported Democrats who align with our values, which is the majority of Democrats running for office in the midterms, keeping in mind that a vote for any Republican is a vote for Donald Trump and his self-serving political agenda.
The 2026 election has already started, and it will end in ten days, when polls close on November 3. We hope you’ll join our efforts to shape the outcome of this election – and ultimately, our children’s future – by joining and supporting our efforts to engage Jewish voters in support of Democrats who share our values.
Shabbat Shalom,
Halie Soifer
CEO, Jewish Democratic Council of America